Title: Forgiven
My Thoughts:
This is a companion novel to Faithful but you do not have to read Faithful in order to understand this book. In this novel Kula Baker is living with her outlaw of a father during the early 1900s. Her father sends her into a town to live with Mrs. Gale in order to try to move up in the world and learn some more manners and lady like behavior. Soon after staying with Mrs. Gale, Kula’s father is put in jail for killing a man. Kula knows that her daddy would never kill antoher human being and her father has instructed her to go to San Francisco in order to get a box. Kula doesn’t want to leave her dad but she decides to go. When she gets there she finds a huge mystery to solve. The big question is will she save her father in time?
Kula started out as such a strong girl, she had to be growing up with a band of outlaw men. I admired her courage but then things quickly started to go downhill for me personally. Kula is Native American and she often stops to refer to herself in the third person such as Kula does not fear this. This almost seemed like a Native American stereotype for me, it reminded me of when Tarzan would grunt and say Tarzan likes this or Tarzan no eat that. It demeaned Kula’s character for me and at only 50 pages into the book I was so close to calling it quits but I pressed on.
Once Kula reaches San Fran the third person narative gets a little better and we start to meet other characters that will help build the mystery. First she will meet a chinese man named David who she instantly likes because he is kind and willing to help her find her way. Later on we will meet a rich boy named Will who is exactly the type of boy that could help Kula gain money and status in the world, which is what she always wanted. Throughout the rest of the story Kula is conflicted between David, who is the guy she likes for himself and Will, who has the money that will help her move up in life.
Overall, the story has a very rough start for me and I’m still at odds with this book because Kula’s character went downhill so fast and she got greedy wanting Will only because of money. While she wants Will for money she claims she is in love with David, who she only meet a month ago, really really tired of the instant love connections in books. All the while she must look for this box that she thinks will help her. Plus added to everything that is going on, is the fact that the ending reminded me of Mockingjay. What I mean by this is that I could respect the ending of this story but it wasn’t exactly where I would have wanted the story to go. The ending was realistic but a bit sad. So even though I finished this book I’m at odds and I give this story 3 hearts because some things just really didn’t work for me.















































